Britain has a habit of describing young people out of work by what they lack. Not enough qualifications. Not enough resilience. Not enough motivation. Alan Milburn’s interim report on Young People and Work calls this habit out directly, observing that young people are too often “described by what they lack”. He is right. And the policy response now being rolled out, for all its scale and good intent, risks repeating the same mistake.

That is why strengths-based coaching for young people deserves a bigger place in the response.

The numbers are stark. Nearly one million 16 to 24 year olds in the UK are not in education, employment or training, around one in eight. Without fundamental change, the review warns, that could rise to one in six, or 1.25 million young people, within five years. Six in ten NEET young people have never had a job, up from four in ten in 2005. The cost to the economy is estimated at up to £125bn a year.

That date, 2005, stopped me. It is the year I launched the UK’s first strengths assessment. In the two decades since, the evidence for building on what people do well has grown steadily. Over the same period, the share of out-of-work young people who have never worked has risen by half. Those two trends should not sit side by side.

Milburn also demolishes the lazy explanation. 84% of NEET young people told the review they want a job, education or training. Willingness is not the problem. Belief, direction and fit are.

The Youth Guarantee Is Welcome. It Is Also Incomplete.

The Government’s answer is the Youth Guarantee, first set out in the Get Britain Working White Paper in November 2024 and now backed by £2.5 billion over three years. According to the House of Commons Library, it includes a Jobs Guarantee offering a paid six-month job to young people who have been on Universal Credit for a long period, a £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant for employers who recruit them, and Youth Hubs, with the Jobs Guarantee rolling out across Great Britain from this month.

The Government has since added 300,000 new work experience and training placements and 50,000 additional youth apprenticeships. Alongside the offer comes tougher conditionality, with young people who turn down work or training at risk of losing benefits.

This matters, and employers should get behind it. But a guarantee creates a door. It does not give a young person the confidence to walk through it, or the self-knowledge to choose the right one.

So, what is missing? Here are the gaps I see, and why strengths-based coaching is built to close them.

We Keep Fixing Deficits Young People Already Know About

Most young people who are NEET can recite their shortcomings in detail. Schools, assessments and benefit interviews have told them often enough. Very few can tell you, with any evidence, what they do well and where that would add value to an employer.

Strengths-based coaching reverses the starting point. It does not ignore weaknesses. The question simply changes from “how do we fix this gap?” to “which of your strengths can help you manage it?”

The research supports the shift. In two field experiments, Meyers and colleagues compared a strengths intervention with a deficiency intervention among students. Both helped, but the strengths group gained more in personal growth initiative, and the effect worked through hope.

Hope is precisely what a young person who has been rejected for two years is short of.

Confidence Is the Barrier, Not Capability

Milburn’s foreword notes that many young people arrive in the workplace anxious and low in confidence. The review also found that the proportion who are NEET and report a work-limiting health condition has risen by around 70% in a decade, while one in five NEET young people now report a mental health condition.

Coaching is not therapy, and it must never be offered as a substitute for proper health support. But for the many young people whose main obstacle is self-doubt, the evidence is encouraging. A controlled study by van Woerkom and Meyers found that a strengths intervention directly increased general self-efficacy, and that it was particularly beneficial for people who lacked confidence in their own abilities. That is the profile of a large share of the young people the Youth Guarantee is trying to reach.

A Placement Without a Sense of Fit Becomes a Revolving Door

The review found that 41% of NEET young people put interesting or fulfilling work as their main priority. Not the highest wage. Not the shortest commute. Work that fits.

A six-month subsidised job is a foundation, not a destination. What happens in month seven depends on whether the young person has discovered what energises them, where they perform at their best, and how to tell that story to the next employer. As Modern HR argues, strengths coaching works because it is personal. No two profiles are the same, so no two plans should be.

Those of us who build assessments are not blameless here. For decades psychometrics asked what type of person someone is and how they compare with everyone else, rather than what they bring to their work at their best. Young people do not need another label. They need a map.

Knowing Your Strengths Is Only Half the Conversation

Strengths are the foundation. On their own they are not a plan. The second half of the conversation is matching what a young person does well, what motivates them and what they value to the skills employers need now, and will need over the next decade.

That demand is not abstract. CITB estimates that construction will need an average of 41,200 extra workers a year between 2026 and 2030. The Government’s Clean Energy Jobs Plan expects clean energy employment to double to 860,000 by 2030, with plumbers, electricians, welders and engineers among 31 priority occupations. And government research suggests that by 2035 around 10 million workers will be in roles where AI is part of the job.

These sectors look very different. They reward overlapping talents. Precision, or attention to detail, matters as much to a site inspector signing off a retrofit as to an analyst checking what an AI tool has produced. A young person driven by purpose may find far more meaning in environmental science or decarbonising homes than in a job chosen simply because it was available. Someone with a natural talent for problem solving and a curious streak may thrive in an engineering apprenticeship they had never considered, because nobody connected the dots for them.

This is where strengths coaching earns its place. A skilled coach helps a young person work through three questions:

  1. Where do my strengths give me a head start?
  2. Which roles fit what motivates me and what I value?
  3. Which skills do I need to build next, and in what order?

Get those answers right and a Youth Guarantee placement stops being a box ticked. It becomes the first rung on a ladder in a growing sector. Skills tell us what someone can do today. Strengths, Motivations and Values tell us where they will keep growing.

Strengths Done Badly Does More Harm Than None

Government has tried this before, and the lesson is worth learning. In 2012 the Behavioural Insights Team ran a Jobcentre trial in Loughton, Essex, which included strengths identification for jobseekers still claiming after eight weeks. The wider package of changes helped people off benefits faster and was rolled out nationally. To be candid, the trial cannot tell us how much of that effect came from the strengths element. And the online questionnaire later used with claimants was exposed by bloggers for producing “strengths” that bore no relation to the answers given.

A list of flattering words is not proper strengths assessment, nor the basis for effective strengths coaching. Real strengths work rests on a validated assessment, a skilled conversation that tests the results against lived evidence, a plan to apply those strengths in a real role, and honest attention to overused strengths that can derail a new starter. Without that rigour, strengths becomes a nudge. With it, it becomes a capability.

That is why I define strengths coaching as a relationship, not a test:

“Building a positive, trusting relationship that helps individuals and teams achieve lasting success by building on strengths and positive capacities, removing blockers, and enabling better choices and growth.”

For a young person who has heard “no” more often than “well done”, every part of that matters. The trust, the focus on what they bring, the honest work on what is in the way, and the better choices that follow.

Careers Support Stops Just When Young People Need It Most

Milburn is blunt about careers guidance in schools, describing it as a statutory duty without enforcement and work experience as haphazard. After education, support thins further, and work coaches carry heavy caseloads.

This is where strengths-based coaching can scale. It does not have to be a premium one-to-one service. It can be built into the first Youth Hub conversation, into how work coaches frame an action plan, and into how employers taking on Jobs Guarantee hires induct and manage them. Train the managers to recognise strengths and give specific positive feedback, and you create a shared language that follows the young person into work.

What Needs to Happen Next

Put these gaps together and the case is clear. Done well, strengths coaching builds three things young people out of work are short of: confidence in what they bring, career clarity about where they fit, and the capability to get there. Those in turn fuel hope, motivation and meaning. Not a pep talk. Not a personality label. A practical foundation for a working life.

That is exactly what young people need right now. And it is exactly what a guaranteed placement cannot supply on its own.

Milburn’s final report, with his recommendations, is still awaited. I would ask for three things:

  1. Start with strengths before gaps. Every Youth Guarantee conversation should begin with a thorough understanding of the underlying talents and Motivations of a young person, evidenced, before it turns to what they lack.
  2. Equip the people around them. Give work coaches, mentors and the line managers of Jobs Guarantee hires practical strengths coaching skills, not another compliance checklist.
  3. Measure what predicts staying power. Track confidence, self-efficacy and fit alongside job starts, so we know whether young people are still in work a year later.

At TalentPredix™ we see this every day through our strengths coaching and our Standout and Succeed™ Early Careers Programme. When young people see their strengths named, validated and put to work, the conversation changes from “what’s wrong with me?” to “where do I fit best?”

Milburn said it plainly when he launched his report: young people today are “not worse, not lazier, not less capable”. To build a thriving society where youth feel a sense of purpose, passion and forward momentum, our job is to help them see it, and then put it to work.

Help Young People Build Confidence, Clarity and Career Direction

TalentPredix™ helps organizations build stronger early-career development around strengths, self-awareness and meaningful career direction. Our Standout and Succeed™ Early Careers Programme combines strengths-based assessment, coaching, workshops and career guidance to help graduates, apprentices and early-career talent make stronger choices and thrive at work.

Explore Early Careers Development

James Brook
Author: James Brook

James Brook FCIPD is the Founder and Managing Director of TalentPredix™, a business psychologist, executive coach and talent and strengths assessment expert with more than 30 years’ international experience. He previously founded Strengthscope® and held senior HR and talent leadership roles at Yahoo!, NatWest and Novo Nordisk.

About the Author

James Brook FCIPD is the Founder and Managing Director of TalentPredix™, a business psychologist, executive coach and talent and strengths assessment expert with more than 30 years’ international experience. He previously founded Strengthscope® and held senior HR and talent leadership roles at Yahoo!, NatWest and Novo Nordisk.